Yes, this is the scenario I was describing.
Ok.
AnyDVD tried unit keys from the keydb until it found one which produced something reasonable.
Maybe.
It's also possible someone generated their own key to match this title and used it with AnyDVD locally.
In which case, the key would have been uploaded to the OPD.
Then when Kaiserbock played it, the key was retrieved from there.
But hadn't been uploaded to the public keyfile.
In fact, this is the most probable scenario as it looks like he didn't update his keyfile between the time he submitted the title to the List and when he found it was supported!
So if it was a matter of AnyDVD using a non-matching unit key in the keyfile, the title would have worked on first pass...
Just to be clear, I’m aware that both have the same keys but the distinction is the additional mapping between disc ID values and keys which is occasionally produced by AnyDVD.
Gotcha.
My suggestion was it would be nice if AnyDVD shared the disc ID to unit key mappings which it identified in this circumstance. AnyDVD wouldn’t be adding new keys to the keydb, I think we all understand that keys only move in one direction between AnyDVD and the keydb…
I see.
What would be the method of sharing you were thinking about?
T