No Sound

Discussion in 'CloneBD' started by Andreask, Jan 26, 2020.

  1. Andreask

    Andreask Active Member

    Hello, I can't get any sound on my stand alone Oppo blue ray play after cloneBD version 1250. I do get sound with power DVD 15 on my laptop and it shows all the sound files even though only the English one is still present. My stand alone also shows all the sound files but no sound, even if the correct one is selected. Even if I don't convert the sound and use the original it still doesn't play on the stand alone. I'm fine using version 1250, it works great, and only shows the one remaining sound file, but I'd like to be able to update just in case. Hope the log file helps. Thanks
     

    Attached Files:

  2. Fabian

    Fabian Developer

    Is this only happening with a specific audio track on the Oppo, or are all audio tracks mute?

    The behavior of TrueHD audio tracks changed after 1.2.5.0
     
  3. Jeff53404

    Jeff53404 Well-Known Member

    Could you please elaborate? My LG (LG UBK90) 4k player will not play TrueHD. I do get sound on my PC.
     
  4. Andreask

    Andreask Active Member

    On the Oppo there is no audio at all. It also happens with DTS-HD. I believe the problem is that it still shows all the audio tracks even though it was encoded with only one. When I encode with version 1250 it only shows the one track.
     
  5. von edmeister 2.0

    von edmeister 2.0 Well-Known Member

    Same on Sony 6500BD. PowerDVD 17 play sound but no stand alone player sound except at very beginning sometimes 1 second of sound and then silence. Firmware updated. Require new codec?
     
  6. Andreask

    Andreask Active Member

    Sounds like the same problem I'm having. Don't believe any updates to your PC are going to solve this. cloneBD isn't deleting empty audio tracks and that might be what's throwing off stand alone Blu Ray players. Until they fix it you can use version 1250, it still works well.
     
  7. von edmeister 2.0

    von edmeister 2.0 Well-Known Member

    Thanks will give it try. Hope CloneBD can fix this soon!
     
  8. Pete

    Pete Forum Admin Staff Member

    I want to get some order into this, there are a lot of important details missing.

    • Are we talking about disc copy (or copy to ISO) or file copy (MKV w. lossless? lossy? audio)? Or both?
    • To be clear: you are all saying, this only came up after CloneBD 1.2.5.0? Meaning 1.2.5.0 is fine?
    • IF we're talking about ISOs or disc copies only: partial copies? complete copies? Both?
    • IF it's partial copies: keep original menu? Don't? Either way?
    Without this information, I guess we'll get nowhere - I did a number of tests with different setups and conversion methods and came up with nothing so far.
    LG doesn't seem to play truehd at all, unless from a disc.
    Oppo plays everything and always, whatever I do.

    I don't see why. CloneBD leaves the empty ones in (only the entries, not the content), whenever the original menu is kept.
    That is in fact the only possible way for the original menus to keep working, because they reference audio tracks by their position in the list (1, 2, 3, ....).
     
  9. von edmeister 2.0

    von edmeister 2.0 Well-Known Member

    Create ISO with AnyDVDHD then load into CloneBD to make partial copy with bonus features and original menu . Burn with IMGburn disc load in stand alone player (2 different Sony 6500 and LG610) always same result no sound on main movie but good sound on bonuses. Problems always on the Dolby tracks and true HD. Do not remember which version CloneBD but has been at least 6 months now. PowerDVD 17 always play disc ok. Strangely the audio track for visually impaired always plays ok. It is only main audio track on movie that doesn't play.
     

    Attached Files:

  10. Andreask

    Andreask Active Member

    I'm talking about a disc copy, it happens with all versions after 1250. Here's a log file using 1281 of a disc copy uncompressed using the original DTS 1.0. The original disc has 4 audio tracks, I unchecked 3 of them but on play back with power DVD it still shows that the new copy still has all 4 tracks. With version 1250 it only shows the one remaining track, not all 4. Same thing with my Oppo, with 1250 it only shows one audio track and with the new versions it shows all the tracks and can't play any of them.. I don't believe the problem is with the audio file but the ghost tracks that is confusing the stand alone players. It does it with all audio track, DTS, TrueHD and LPCM.
     

    Attached Files:

  11. Andreask

    Andreask Active Member

    Don't know if this will be of any help but here is the same movie using version 1250 with the same setting and it only shows the one selected audio track, not all 4 like with every version after 1250.
     

    Attached Files: