I own the Epson R320 and R1800 printers and have found them to be excellent printers. The only problem I see with all Epson printers is you have to use the power button on the printer it's self to properly park the print head. If you do not use the printer for an extended period and you do not use the power button to shut it off, you will run the risk of plugging the print head.
I have a good friend who recently bought the HP d5160 and he likes it very much.
It is not an expensive printer and is somewhat noisey and a little slow, but other than that, it seems like a pretty nice printer for the money.
The printed discs look to be on a par with my R320 and the Photo prints are also very nice though the R320 Photo prints seem a bit more crisp and vibrant.
But hey, my friend only paid $90.00 for the HP at Walmart and for 90 bucks it's pretty sweet.
The only real downside I can see to the HP is he has had a small problem with paper feeding.
If the paper is not too heavy and is flat it feeds fine, but heavy paper with a bit of warp in it jams pretty consistantly.
If you keep your paper nice and flat you should have no problem, but old heavy photo paper that you have had laying around too long may pose a problem.