The Martian - AnyDVD Yes - DVDFab No?

Discussion in 'General Chat' started by TheEmpathicEar, Jan 27, 2018.

  1. TheEmpathicEar

    TheEmpathicEar Well-Known Member

    The Martian, 2015. I tried to rip this using DVDFab and got a read error during the initial analysis. So, I used AnyDVD and got a successful rip [to image] w/o even so much a "Retry". I am just curious. A read error is a read error? How can AnyDVD [apparently] do something that DVDFab can not?
     
  2. StoneyJSG

    StoneyJSG Well-Known Member

    From what I gander is that the makers of AnyDVD are on top of things and can get by protection mechanisms faster than the fab guys can. Hence why AnyDVD was able to rip it. Fab has trouble with BD+ where AnyDvD does not. This is why I only have 2 fab products and wish I only had 1.
     
  3. TheEmpathicEar

    TheEmpathicEar Well-Known Member

    Yeh, but I got a read error [or what appeared to be a read error] with DVDfab. And, it was during the initial analysis. Usually, these read errors happen during the copy phase.
     
  4. Lukas

    Lukas Well-Known Member

    I will buy for myself every time I am a very satisfied user soon will be added full UHD support
     
  5. TheEmpathicEar

    TheEmpathicEar Well-Known Member

    Yeh, I am a happy AnyDVD user too. However, it's nice to try something else every now and then...
     
  6. Lukas

    Lukas Well-Known Member

    DVDFAB has a bad crack method these boys are doing there are amateurs :p
     
  7. Lukas

    Lukas Well-Known Member

    I made a comparison between DVDFAB and ANYDVD and ANYDVD a clear choice of DVDFAB but shortly it will be incredibly laughing when I see my cause I can not believe that in this field they have nothing to ask only the lantern of people money for bad work
     
  8. James

    James Redfox Development Team Staff Member

    Maybe just a coincidence, Fab using different method for their hashes or AnyDVD is using more retries after read errors (AnyDVD tries quite often).
     
  9. coopervid

    coopervid Well-Known Member

    Just a quick hint. AnyDVD skips read errors after a while. Such backups will fail with CloneBD etc. if you have a copy of the failed disc with read errors. You can play it but I haven't tried to burn such a imperfect copy. Most likely that won't work.
     
  10. Lukas

    Lukas Well-Known Member

    James when I made comparative backup tests with DVDFAB and ANYDVD in the TRIAL mod and deciding which products to choose to have won the REDFOX team, you have backed up my film in good quality with no mistakes unlike DVDFAB so I decided for your team and today I am very happy
     
  11. TheEmpathicEar

    TheEmpathicEar Well-Known Member

    Ah, yes, I noticed that the read rate [probably a better term for this] slowed down quite a bit in some places. This is one example of AnyDVD doing retries?
     
  12. James

    James Redfox Development Team Staff Member

    No, it doesn't. Unless you tell it to do this, of course. Or there is a bug I am unable to reproduce.