I will try not to go off on a tangent here, but I would like to say that I really do appreciate and value the time and effort our moderators spend on this forum.
Maintaining such a list of "BDs that will work" would be rather difficult, for all the reasons mentioned before, and the mere fact that not everybody will meticulously list things that will work, which would render the list incomplete, which would then lead to false negatives (users assuming a title won't work because it is not listed).
If you are willing to start and maintain such a list, a better and more viable idea might be to list titles that will not work in a single thread (rather than multiple threads with the same title as we experience frequently). This would have to be maintained, meaning: the user who lists a specific title ought to remove it from the list once the issue has been resolved, as they are the ones who will know first if it works.
Such a list is bound to be much shorter than one with all the titles that will work as well, simply because AnyDVD HD really is that awesome.