I just checked using VLC 2.2.2 with AnyDVD enabled. I made interesting observations.
- If you select to play "Open Disc" as in accessing the DVD from my optical drive and have the advanced settings > Input/Codecs > Access Modules > DVD with Menus > DVDnav Input > "Start Directly in Menu" checked then Title 1 will play which is 2:16:50 and the proper playlist.
- Regardless of the Start Directly in Menu setting if you "Open Disc" and select the DVD from the optical drive and check the "No disc menus" box then Title 1 will play which is 2:16:50 and the proper playlist.
- If you "Open Disc" and do not check "No disc menus" and do do not have "Start Directly in Menu" checked then Title 25 which is 2:26:00 will play and this is obviously the bad playlist.
It comes down to luck and settings, apparently, in VLC. PowerDVD15 just fails to play properly.
It would appear the "problem" with protection is somewhere leading up to the menus? I'm no developer. They'll figure it out.
Note: I'm dealing with my retail disc.