THANK YOU!!!!! I really can't tell you how much this means to me.Very well said, Peer!
Good point. But AnyDVD has a similar problem, as we have witnessed with SlySoft vanishing. Without the server infrastructure it isn't so useful anymore.
To prevent this from happening again, we should find a way to make the OPD is available offline. This isn't as easy as it sounds.
First, all data - including Java based protections - must be cached locally.
The OPD is a "moving target". Publish monthly snapshots? Weekly? Daily?
Add time stamps to the database entries, so people with expired licenses can't use new discs?
We don't need to implement this right away - as there are some more urgent matters - but we should keep it on our todo list.
It's not like they don't know what it needs to decode their discs. They're more interested in what AnyDVD can not do, I guess. Also if they wanted to, they could just get a license and let AnyDVD decode it.The shell is useless to the programmers in Hollywood as they won't be able to read the opds with the 128 bit encryption key which you guys control.
Why not just try to get a mirror system set up for OPD?
TF is a love/hate thing for me too. I dislike seeing biased posts. At least 95% of Bluray rips on pirate sites are not in their original format, and transcoding can be done without the use of any BD decrypter it just requires a HDCP stripper and a recorder.I've been scanning through the many, many posts from the recent days and especially one post with a link to some blog entry over at torrentfreak ruined my day a bit. It's not the actual message (for who didn't read it: it's all about the poor pirates, now having no tool for their glorious doings).
After all, torrentfreak is all about file sharing and it's not my place to judge what's right and what's wrong (though I do have a strong personal dislike for piracy).
I don't think you can say whether piracy hurts industries or not without evidence. As TF points out in another post, Gramstad (2016) found that piracy has hurt Linux adoption and helped Microsoft keep dominance over the PC and Windows laptop markets.Piracy is an issue. You can't deny that it is hurting the movie industry. And you can't deny that we were involuntarily helping piracy. Just like the glass cutter involuntarily helps burglary.
I doubt that's wholly accurate, however people can rent discs or borrow them for free legally with no royalties going to publishers. The fact is that people do often have other legal options other than buying a DVD.Though you can argue over the numbers. They like to pretend that every single downloaded movie is one sold disc less. Of course that is utter nonsense. A lot of that stuff gets downloaded simply because it's there. At least 99 out of 100 downloads are done by people who wouldn't even consider paying for the disc. And I'm willing to bet, that 99% is too cautious an estimate.
I doubt that's wholly accurate, however people can rent discs or borrow them for free legally with no royalties going to publishers. The fact is that people do often have other legal options other than buying a DVD.
As far as OPD etc is concerned, I would be happy if putting every disk I bought into the drive and letting Anydvd scan it would ensure that i could always read that disk. So my collection would always be safe, but no guarantees about any future purchase. And I think that would be a fair deal on both sides, and should be relatively easy to implement.